Riverside Info » About Riverside

Architecture

(68 posts)
  • Started 5 years ago by ChrisHajer
  • Latest reply from spatny
  1. ChrisHajer
    Member

    Shamelessly stolen from http://www.joelonsoftware.com/items/2006/12/15.html

    Alain de Botton, writing in The Architecture of Happiness (Pantheon Books, 2006):

    He compares the Salginatobel Bridge, in Switzerland...
    saltinobel bridge in switzerland

    ...to the Clifton Suspension Bridge, in England:
    clifton suspension bridge england

    “Both Robert Maillart's Salginatobel and Isambard Brunel's Clifton Suspension bridges are structures of strength; both attract our veneration for carrying us safely across a fatal drop—”and yet Maillart's bridge is the more beautiful of the pair for the exceptionally nimble, apparently effortless way in which it carries out its duty. With its ponderous masonry and heavy steel chains, Brunel's construction has something to it of a stocky middle-aged man who hoists his trousers and loudly solicits the attention of others before making a jump between two points, whereas Maillart's bridge resembles a lithe athlete who leaps without ceremony and bows demurely to his audience before leaving the stage. Both bridges accomplish daring feats, but Maillart's possesses the added virtue of making its achievement look effortless—”and because we sense it isn't, we wonder at it and admire it all the more. The bridge is endowed with a subcategory of beauty we can refer to as elegance, a quality present whenever a work of architecture succeeds in carrying out an act of resistance—”holding, spanning, sheltering—”with grace and economy as well as strength; when it has the modesty not to draw attention to the difficulties it has surmounted.—

    Posted Sunday Dec 17, 2006 21:31 #
  2. ChrisHajer
    Member

    Amazing how much architecture stuff comes across the geek radar:

    More online at http://www.greatbuildings.com/pix/picture_index_010.html

    Posted Wednesday Jan 31, 2007 16:31 #
  3. Catherine
    Member

    Chris, what's that one above Fallingwater?

    How do you get these pix to go onto here? I tried it once but couldn't do it! Have you ever checked out Isfahan, Iran? Too bad they're busy "developing" it. I guess they're not worried about tourism, anyway.

    Posted Wednesday Jan 31, 2007 17:21 #
  4. ChrisHajer
    Member

    Above Falling Water is Santa Maria Novella Church in Florence Italy, built c. 1456-1470. We had the pleasure of seeing it in person. If you click the picture above, you will go to a site with more information.

    To insert a picture into a post, first, it needs to be accessible online somewhere. Then, once you have the URL (the web address) of the picture, you insert it into a post like this:

    <img src="http://www.somewebsite.com/funnypic.jpg" />

    and that's it. If you don't get the syntax exactly right, it is just stripped from your post, like it was never there. If you need help, let me know.

    Oh, and regarding Isfahan, Iran: I had never looked but I have now. I was going to post a picture but I will leave that as an exercise for you. :)

    Chris

    Posted Wednesday Jan 31, 2007 17:59 #
  5. MikeT
    Member

  6. spatny
    Member

    So here's what we could have had instead of the VC, and we would have all the traffic we need forever. We could even let the EDC go.

    We would have become the ground zero of American architectural interest. Too bad - no imagination...

    Posted Wednesday Jan 31, 2007 20:23 #
  7. spatny
    Member

    A case in point...
    Developer Wins Court Battle to Demolish Building
    CNY Business Journal (1996+), Jul 07, 2000 by Allen, Paul

    SYRACUSE - The owner's lawyer calls the building a "rathole," while the president of the local preservationist association says it's a unique historical work by one of the city's master architects of the 19th century. So far, tile city's planning commission and the state's court system have backed owner Tino Marcoccia, and approved his plans to tear down the 105-year-old Conrad Loos building on the city's North Side.

    A New York State Supreme Court judge recently upheld the Syracuse City Planning Commission's decision to grant Marcoccia a Certificate of Appropriateness to demolish the building and dismissed the Preservation Association of Central New York's (PACNY) arguments regarding the legality of the procedure, PACNY's lawsuit contended that the actions of the planning commission in granting the certificate, and in failing to refer its decision to the Common Council for review, were illegal, arbitrary, and an abuse of discretion. The Preservation Association also contended that Marcoccia's economic hardship was self-created.

    Robert Tisdell, attorney for Marcoccia, was pleased with the court's decision and questioned the motivation behind PACNY's lawsuit. "I'm all for preserving historically important buildings, but not ones that are allowed to deteriorate to this level, This building is a rathole - it's a dilapidated, empty, eyesore. If these people (PACNY) wanted to save this building so badly, where were they 15 years ago?"

    Don't think it can't happen to the ARCADE!

    Posted Wednesday Jan 31, 2007 21:22 #
  8. Catherine
    Member

    Oh, yes, Santa Maria Novella, the church next to the train station. I too saw it in 1993. Yes, one is fortunate indeed to visit Italy: a place that knows how to meet the need of its contemporary citizens and visitors whilst preserving it and avoiding turning it into a monstrous dump.

    Isfahan, one site:

    Posted Thursday Feb 1, 2007 07:49 #
  9. HRCollins
    Member

    Spatny -

    I do like the building you posted but something like that would be cost and space prohibitive to build for retail in Riverside as ADA laws would require elevators to be built. I know the VC has elevators for the residents but the residents will not want to share with public just as the residents do not share with the office tenants and shoppers in the John Hancock Center.

    I will wait to judge the VC until its completion.

    Posted Thursday Feb 1, 2007 09:23 #
  10. spatny
    Member

    HR - it was just put here to stimulate the senses. When Hundertwasser built this in Vienna it instantly became one of the major attractions of a world capital with many attractions - and it has a waiting list a mile long. What I meant to illustrate was that if we had built something interesting instead of more of this mundane, ugly and oversize crap we could have solved a couple problems at the same time by attracting people once again to see new and interesting architecture. People come to Riverside to see the Tomek and Coonley houses, some of the other Prairie Style homes like Thorncroft, and the older significant structures - not this junk. Riverside is world famous as a planned LANDSCAPE and we should, if we are really to redevelop the CBD, think about doing something worthy of it - not, again, more of this oversize, out-of-scale trash.

    Posted Thursday Feb 1, 2007 10:33 #

RSS feed for this topic

Reply »

You must log in to post.